iPhone 4 Antennas: The Fun Side

We’ll leave serious industry matters aside this week. (If you must, you can wade into Apple’s Q3 numbers here, or luxuriate in the impending ouster of Nokia CEO OPK and consider the list of possible replacements.)

Instead, we’ll look into the fun side of Apple’s antenna, or antennas (not antennae, a solecism from last week. A reader reminded me that antennae is reserved for actual bugs, as in insects.)

As they always do, savvy entrepreneurs immediately saw how to convert a problem into an opportunity, how to spin an unintended “feature” into $$.

Tongue-in-cheekiest of them all, we have Antenn-aid:

Nothing more need be said.

Etsy’s offering is a bit less subtle:

(and the pricetag is $4, not the $29 shown in the picture.) The label is a intentionally contradicatory: Placing the sticker over the gap will prevent involuntarily dropped calls, but the humor (and the product) works.

Let’s talk bumpers.

I like the sleek industrial design of the iPhone 4 but because the bumper and the charging dock are mutually exclusive, I’ve remained defiantly “unprotected.” I should have known better. One small slip of the hand, one bounce off the concrete and…

The local Apple store folks tried to console me: ‘Oh, this is nothing. Do you know why we have moisture sensors inside the iPhone? No idea? Ok, what’s the smallest room in your house? Yes, that one. The phone slips out of the jeans pocket and…”

I got luckier when I ordered a custom decal for the back of my iPhone. GelaSkins, a gem of a Canadian company, make skins for laptops, smartphones of almost any brand, and now iPads. Over the years, they’ve managed to incorporate interesting art, from Van Gogh to punk and Japanese street art (you can see their gallery here)

Recently, they’ve started offering custom skins: Create your very own special decal showing a picture of your family, your dog, your yacht or even your boss (if you think that will help). You upload a picture, crop it to fit your phone or laptop and they’ll ship you a neat decal printed on a clever 3M adhesive. It’s clever because it works for klutzes such as yours truly: Tiny channels crisscross the sticky side of the decal. One quick swipe and the air bubbles magically disappear. And, of course, no one gets the placement right the first time, or the second, or even the third (I know this from personal experience). With the GelaSkin adhesive you can try again and again until you get it right.

(Full disclosure: I have no relationship with GelaSkins other than being a full-price, satisfied customer.)

For my older iPhone, I submitted a picture from a now defunct art store on rue Saint Placide in Paris:

When I got my new iPhone 4, I repeated the process with the same picture and got a welcome surprise. GelaSkin knows the difference between the 3GS back skin:

…and the back of the iPhone 4:

The arrows at the top right point to three holes: one for the Mute button, the other two for the + and – keys on the phone’s side. Furthermore, the skin incorporates a correctly placed cutout for the camera and LED flash:

What I didn’t expect were two separate wrap-around skins for the phone’s sides, yielding this:

Reacting to critics, Apple has pointed to the weak spot on its interesting Antenna Performance page…

..but my custom skin covers the sides and the weak spot is “healed”:

Is it modesty or merely a combination of luck and ignorance? The Gelaskins site makes no mention of the “bonus feature”.

Let’s turn to an even sunnier side of the street. During his years at Pacific Bell, Scott Adams created the long running and still sharp Dilbert comics series, lampooning corpocatric culture and the drones infesting large organizations. You can find Scott’s insight into Job’s handling of the iPhone antennas problem (The High Ground Maneuver) on his blog. And, while you’re there, take a look at his weigh-ins on the iPad and Active Listening. I feel a little embarrassed to have only recently discovered Scott’s blog, but I’ve entered it into my Google Reader subscriptions.

One more Monday Note next week, then we go on break for two weeks.

JLG@mondaynote.com

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google Bookmarks
  • LinkedIn
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis

Related columns:

  1. iPhone 3G — One Week Later Contrary to what I expected, the dust hasn’t settled yet. A week later, people still queue, 2h30 Friday morning before being admitted to the sanctum sanctorum in San Francisco. Besides the long lines, there were glitches: activation problems, trouble with the new MobileMe service, with getting access to software updates for the “old” iPhones. Apple [...]...
  2. iPhone Applications: Apple people now believe in a Supreme Being No, no, not Steve Jobs but an even higher entity smiling upon the company. As I hope to show, Apple’s hard work years ago is now about to pay huge unexpected dividends on the iPhone. When the iPhone first came out of Steve Jobs’ quasi-divine hands in January 2007, it was a hack, the result [...]...
  3. Time to think seriously about the iPhone 4:00am. I find myself reading an interesting story covering Portfolio’s web site – on my iPhone. As sleep comes back, I reflexively reach for the “save” (for later reading) button that is on every iPhone news application. But I am reading from the magazine’s site, as opposed to running an app on my smartphone; web [...]...
  4. Mobile publishing — Why publishers should grab the iPhone News publishers remain obsessed with the question: what will be the main distribution platform for their contents, and what will be the subsequent business models? For clues, let’s zoom in the iPhone’s recent performances as well as its immediate prospects. The smartphone introduced a year ago by Apple has become the tool of choice for [...]...
  5. The Real iPhone 1.0 Saint Peter offers a choice of hells to a recently dematerialized high-tech tycoon (pick your favorite sinner) with a long list of transgressions. The basic one, fire, floggings, and the premium one, plenty of music, drink, food and other pleasures of the flesh. Said tycoon picks the fun venue, Saint Peter pulls a lever, the [...]...

8 Comments

  1. PXLated
    Posted July 25, 2010 at 10:09 pm | Permalink

    Love that picture skin!!
    Thanks for sharing.

  2. Posted July 25, 2010 at 10:39 pm | Permalink

    Two weeks off? In August! And you call yourself French;-)
    Great post. Buyers shouldn’t let Apple off easy.

  3. evilbillcosby
    Posted July 26, 2010 at 2:04 am | Permalink

    actually, the thin gelaskin probably doesn’t do much in terms of blocking attenuation ( you need more thickness)

    clearly you are still coming to a full understanding of the situation
    please get caught up soon

  4. Jean-Louis Gassée
    Posted July 26, 2010 at 4:08 am | Permalink

    @evilbillcosby:
    Here is what I know from personal experience: on the same location, same time of the day, we have my wife’s unprotected iPhone and mine, skinned. On both phones, I put my finger on what Apple calls the weak spot.
    My wife’s phone lose two bars, mine none.
    I’m tempted to try clear nail polish applied over the antenna gap, but my wife won’t let me play with her phone… JLG

  5. Canucker
    Posted July 26, 2010 at 4:17 pm | Permalink

    On you pictures of the iPhone4, you can still see the diagonal lines criss-crossing the top and bottom 20% of the device, Did you not squeeze out the Gelaskin here (to emphasize the point) or is this an artefact of the picture?

    IMHO, the art crayon picture is perfect for the back the phone but the side images are too thin and look a little messy and crowded.

  6. Posted July 27, 2010 at 6:37 am | Permalink

    wow, that’s really a good skin

  7. Paul Camp
    Posted August 30, 2010 at 4:16 am | Permalink

    And yet it still doesn’t strike you as stupid to build a device intended to ride around in your pocket out of glass?

    Form over function is not a good idea.

  8. Posted August 30, 2010 at 4:25 am | Permalink

    Glass-Stupid? No, people carried pocket watches around for decades with glass & crystal faces, some two sided, even in heavy industry. Not a problem in a pocket, maybe a problem if you drop it on concrete.

7 Trackbacks

  1. By Ein Pflaster für iPhone 4 : T e c Z i l l a on July 25, 2010 at 10:44 pm

    [...] Produktempfehlungen verdanken wir dem immer unterhaltsamen Jean-Louis Gasséé. Er hätte aber vielleicht doch den von Apple angeratenen [...]

  2. By pligg.com on July 26, 2010 at 2:45 am

    iPhone 4 Antennas: The Fun Side…

    We’ll leave serious industry matters aside this week. Instead, we’ll look into the fun side of Apple’s antenna, or antennas (not antennae, a solecism from last week. A reader reminded me that antennae is reserved for actual bugs, as in insects.) As the…

  3. [...] iPhone 4 Antennas: The Fun Side | Monday Note [...]

  4. [...] to MondayNote.com, Apple iPhone decals are becoming all the rage in the fad realm as users are applying everything [...]

  5. [...] iPhone 4 Antennas: The Fun Side | Monday Note [...]

  6. [...] iPhone-4- und GelaSkins-Kunde berichtet, dass die Folie tatsächlich das Empfangsproblem verkleinert. Der Preis für die Folie liegt bei [...]

  7. [...] Gassée / Monday Note:iPhone 4 Antennas: T&#1211&#1077 Fun Side  —  W&#1077′ll leave serious industry matters aside t&#1211&#1110&#1109 [...]

Post a Comment

Your email is never shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*